COP27 in Conversation with Gandhi...

So, what if a delegate from India were to explain to Gandhi at the COP27 as to what exactly was happening there? So went the imagination during a train journey….

Characters -

Indian Delegate: S is an middle aged IAS officer from Delhi, thinks of himself as pragmatic, now in COP27 as part of the Indian delegation.  

Gandhi – landed from heaven and for the sake of convenience we assume that he was following the developments, so  we need not explain a lot of the current craziness.

Dialogue -

Gandhi: S, please tell me why are you in Egypt.

S, IAS: Thank you Bapu, first of all, happy to have your august presence here with us. We are so happy that you could attend this historic meeting.

G: what is historic about this meeting?

S: well, this is the first time such a conference is being held in an African country, Egypt. So, that is a good beginning and we hope that we will be able to highlight the plight of the poorer countries and seek the compensation that they deserve in the first place for all the climate change losses from the rich countries.

G: what are the losses that the poorer countries suffer due to climate change?

S: why Bapu, as you know the natural resources of the poorer countries are mined, destroyed or exploited for the benefit of the rich countries. Apart from that the  global warming for which the rich countries have contributed now affect the aspirations and the goals  of the poorer countries as well. They can’t imagine themselves going in the direction of the rich countries, they have to chart a different path for themselves. This will take effort and cost money.

G: So, this conference is essentially for the rich countries to compensate the poor?

S: You got it right Bapu. This will give them poorer countries with the strength to pursue their development.

G: Long ago I had spoken of Trusteeship, however that was different from this. You talk of compensation, will it provide the poorer countries the capacity to overcome their ecological challenges and also economic ones?

S: Sure, Bapu. They can also develop economically and reach the levels of prosperity of the rich countries bridging the economic gap.  

G: Wait, Why should they go in the same path as the rich countries?

S: why can’t they? We in India have done that. We have now more cars than many countries in Europe put together. We have more airplanes, high speed highways, etc., that is the normal aspiration to develop.

G: but didn’t you mention that such development is what caused the exploitation of natural resources in the first place in the poorer countries? So, obviously, they will be exploited even if poorer countries were to mine or destroy them.

S: yes, but that is a choice we need to have.

G: assuming everyone had that choice, do you think anyone will choose another path? For instance any of the poorer countries that you are talking about, will they do it if this COP manages to get them the required funds?

S: that is upto them as a nation or a society. Look at us we have adopted a more social model of development.  We have incorporated all these welfare schemes to ensure that no one is left out, we have permitted politicians to promise and deliver all kinds of social benefits to the weaker sections in the country though we know it is a drain in exchequer.

G: if you think it is a ‘’drain’’ why do it then?

S: well, like I said we don’t want to leave anyone behind.

G: if you are so far ahead that you need to ‘’drain’’ resources to bring someone to your level, don’t you think the mistake could be with you?

S:how can that be? We have had the privilege of several generations of education and exposure to larger world, so, our payback to society is to ensure that we advance economically. That cannot surely be called as ‘’moving far ahead’’. Aap aisa keisa bolte hein bapu?

G: but do you consider yourself from this country?

S: of course, I am a nationalist and a patriot. hum 100% desh bakth hain!

G: what qualifies you to do that?

S: I have joined the civil service despite having a PhD and being a student in one of the largest universities in the country. I work day and night for the benefit of the people of this country. I have strong views on all those who weaken this country and its development and within whatever power I have, I will ensure that they don’t win.

G:  why do you say that ‘despite’ having a PhD you joined the civil service?

S: well, I could have had better paying opportunities and could have even gone abroad, instead I chose to sacrifice all those to work for the government.

G: what exactly did you ‘sacrifice’? I understand that your father was also an officer. So, you came from a privileged class, what is the sacrifice?

S: well, like my children have chosen to go abroad now for their higher studies. I could have gone abroad and got a job with far better salary.

G: so, in your eyes, getting better salary or working abroad is a better form of development than working for your own government? Is that why you sent your children abroad?

S: I didn’t necessarily mean it that way Gandhiji, children need to make their own choice. You are now like the trolls twisting my words to mean something else

G: no I am only saying what you have said already more directly.  If serving your own people is seen as ‘’coming down’’ in payment scale or catering to the needs of the poor and marginalized is seen as a ‘’drain’’, then basically you are identifying yourself with someone who is not an Indian. In my eyes, you are more closer to being what is popular these days as ‘anti-national’

S: Bapu that is a strong accusation. We started to talk about the COP27, I don’t know how we ended up talking about me now. I am not the subject here.

G: But your attitude and what you have come to represent is the real problem. You mentioned earlier that you are here in the COP27 to ensure that the poorer countries are compensated by the rich one for dirtying the world. Yes, but if that doesn’t stop the rich countries from further dirtying and if it encourages the poorer countries to further dirty the world, then what is the point of the meeting or the compensation? This is the same as what you mentioned about the marginalized people in India as much as it is the same for the poorer countries elsewhere. Unless such a compensation is not leading us to do a joint reflection on what is the path of ‘economy’ that we choose and term it ‘development’ and how do we jointly address its challenges, we continue to delude somehow that we are able to make changes that will result in somehow a different world. We cannot create a different world by transacting within the existing world – which is what the compensation is – we change by changing everyone together, each one in their space needs to change. Some may have to tax excessive wealth and consumption heavily, but, also provide structure and systems to exit from such consumption dependent industries. Others will have to think of how to find joy in life and contentment without having to consume as much as those who have destructively consumed.

  

losing a talented young story teller... Ankit Chadha

Rama Subramanian is at Xavier University, Bhubaneswar.

January 30 · Bhubaneswar

an amazing story telling session on Gandhi by Ankit Chadha and Vedanth Bharadwaj at XUB. i have heard the Bapu Katha before but something about the quality of music, the choice of lyrics, the pause and silence, story telling style...perhaps one of the most moving story telling that I have seen in recent times.

...this was Jan 30th. it remains the most moving story telling of Bapu, I have heard and I have heard Narain bhai Desaiji live as well. there was this moment during the session when the security personnel of the Governor of Odisha turned up with their security devices and dogs. he was supposed to come up for the next session and the security personnel were there to do a 'check-up', but Ankit and Vedanth were just then getting into the most important part of the story telling, it was about the last day of Gandhiji..."let the Governor come, this is prarthana, let him sit and participate in it, we cannot stop now", said Ankit and he had the entire set of students and all the speakers who were there backing him up. Vijay Mahajan, Shiv Vishwanath...every one of them stood up in solidarity. The story telling continued even as the anxious security personnel and the increasingly agitated organizers tried in vain to negotiate, Ankit and Vedanth ignored them and continued the prarthana..."Gandhi cannot have such a treatment in this country, it is his story", quipped someone...the VC had to come into the picture, request everyone as the Governor was already on the way and the security personnel had to do their duty...so, as the angry duo stepped out of the auditorium, so did everyone of us who were scheduled to speak in the conference, and so did most of the students. such was the power of the story telling that almost every one of those present was apologizing to each other, students walked up and apologized to the speakers...the governor's programme was like a long pause...at the end of which the entire gathering re-convened as Ankit finished the prarthana along with Vedanth.

the VC personally apologized to each and everyone present. It was a moment where an educational institution caught in its own systemic necessities had to compromise a moment of intense experience and learning and everyone had a bad feeling about it..but, it was also a moment of victory for the story of Bapu and the story teller par excellence who created the magic that would stay with everyone for long...i have been listening to his voice several time since morning, from my memory and from online and reading up...probably the 1 person who made the biggest impact on me during the first encounter this year and have been looking forward so much to be working with him. now he is gone. Sara Wolcott sent a small piece of music in mourning today, have listened to it a few times, but, the heaviness doesn't go. world cannot lose such people so young. Gandhi and this country deserve better than lose this man this way...