Join this Group for Updates and Discussions on this Blog (and a few others)!

Google Groups Join
Showing posts with label satyagraha. Show all posts
Showing posts with label satyagraha. Show all posts

Monday, December 08, 2008

Why hasn't anyone banned 'Rail Roko Dharna' yet?

The Indian Railways transports large amount of our population from home to work every day and reaches much larger number of essential commodities for our people. It qualifies as an 'essential service' certainly. 


So, why do we allow people to stop trains from going on time just to show their anger and dissent on one thing or another? Why does the state and the railway department permit people this photo opportunity?


Yesterday noticed yet another 'rail roko' announcement in a large poster, a group has announced that it would stop train to show their protest in different towns on different days! And has its leader stopping another train, sure enough for some other issue on an earlier occasion. It was as though the stopping of train was a birth right of any political party or movement for any kind of protest? Why does the nation state and department allow people's essential service to be held at ransom?


One can understand the spontaneous gesture of road roko that often happens in our rural areas where a group of  villagers resort to it to ensure that people passing by their village pay attention to the status of the village, but, a pre-planned, announced (and celebrated) kind of rail roko does not stem from the same spirit. It was as though the state was happy as long as people were dissenting in certain ways that it can watch and manage.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Getting 'Gandhi' off our backs!

Samanvaya Freedom Lecture last evening witnessed a brief moment of ugliness. I am not sure whether this is getting to be common and accepted these days. During the interaction session an elderly man came up to the dias and claimed that 'Gandhi did not get us Independence, it was Hitler who got it for us', and went on to call Gandhiji names and finally ended with, 'its time we got Gandhi off our backs'. One could see that he was sincere in his belief of what he was saying, if there are many such, we are really in a sorry condition. Though I briefly responded to this person at the platform itself, realized that this could be a problem much larger.

Such intense Gandhi bashing is a great way of retaining him 'on our backs' and perhaps bashing is a political and social compulsion to some groups and organizations because of their orientation and policies.

There are sophisticated variations of the same feeling, 'humanizing gandhi', 'criticing Gandhi', etc. which may have scholarly needs, but, when combined with the mass marketing hype and mindless media spread only highlight the easily excitable parts and leave and broadcast them widely. One recalls what happened to the attempts of Rajmohan Gandhi in writing his voluminous Gandhi book where just that one instance of Sarala Devi excited the mass media.

Then there is the quick content fix for the mass media, I witnessed recently two different mass media displays / presentations on Gandhi both of which did not have anything more than what our 8th standard text book says on him. With about a 100 publications in his name every year, it seems pitiable that the visual media that chockes our public spaces increasingly cannot dig up more information that that.

But, is 'getting Gandhi off our back really a problem of the people of this country?', I think know. Gandhi has become a benchmark and occupies our popular idiom far too much for us to get rid of him that easily. He is used in day to day to connote anything to do with truth and peace. In Chennai, 'gandhi kanakku' or 'account it on Gandhi' is rather popular saying for any money that is not to be returned. I don't know what is the history of this term, but, it is normally connoted with giving for charity or public good! Similarly, 'don't sound like you are a Gandhi' is a popular say among students that means 'be pretentious of truthfulness', 'in this land of gandhi...' is used as  a social commentary by everyone from supreme court judge to news paper columnist and increasingly bloggers, recently the ex-CM of Karnataka surprised everyone by stating on the floor of the state assembly that in the current political environment it would be difficult for 'Gandhi to survive...'!

Gandhi is only a popular term today for a set of values that are of higher order. As long as there is a memory of Gandhi and a natural aspiration towards these higher values, I think we will continue to invoke him in our discourse. Truth and Non-Violence have not yet become too alien to the Indian public, they still aspire for it and there is a constant urge to find the truth and protests are still stage in non-violent manner in various parts apart from constructive non-violence being practised by the majority who rarely make it to the popular media. Getting rid of him should only affect those who either burden themselves with his persona too much or who have migrated too far from the life of the majority and seek to build their lives around values that are contrary to the majority, perhaps then the strong contra becomes unbearable.

Read by Label