Join this Group for Updates and Discussions on this Blog (and a few others)!

Google Groups Join
Showing posts with label PM. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PM. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

would we miss this PM?


in the last few days now, no one has seen the P.M. He is supposed to be under medical care. but, has the nation missed him?

my question is not to do with the nuclear deal in which the PM seems to be more bent than any other deal. inflation, oil prices, new coastal regulation policy that no one wants, bhopal victims (whoever has the energy and is still alive) on a long hunger strike in delhi, sikkim having youth on hunger strike protesting against a unnecessary dam, prof. agarwal continuing his hunger strike in uttarkashi despite threats from local politicians, gujjar problem in rajasthan, shiv sena renewed issues in maharashtra, the continuing farmer suicide...much else happens in the country. but, the PM is stuck on the nuclear deal. one day he says, 'take it or I quit', next day he seems to say, 'take it or I will not go to G7', who will miss you? we don't miss you certainly.

MM Singh has forever been media darling because of his demenear, so much so that we have forgotten that he probably is the weakest PM we have ever got in this country. not even during the short stints of Gujral and Gowda would have been as weak as now. He has no respect in his party, certainly no power. His party leader to save the government, consults Balu, a minister who admits to being corrupt in the floor of the Parliament; his cabinet colleagues openly fight each other through press statements, he doesn't hail from anywhere nor does he have a following except among his own category of babus in global babu institutions such as World Bank and UN and local bureaucracy. He was never elected through an election that was actually fought. He is 'clean' from the taint of the Indian politics and the only people who celebrate him are the middle class whose general knowledge is fed by the English visual media and who in turn feed it with their half baked opinions.

his carefully spoken English is a darling of those masses who have learnt their English in English medium schools so that they can go abroad and 'make a lot of money', his greatest achievement has been that he ushered in those changes that would have been brought in by any one, because there was no choice but to liberalize. his greatest beneficiaries - the corporates laughed at his face when he suggested voluntary cuts in pay scale and all but booed him for suggesting reservation in their ranks.

MM Singh is a rank outsider in the congress. he is part of a long list of bureaucrats turned politicians of the 80s and 90s that is a trend in Indian politics. it includes the popular presidents such as K.R. Narayan and Kalam and quite a few ministers including Yashwant Sinha, Mani Iyer, etc. This entire bunch of people had their 'international' reputations to back them up and no popular support among people either through mandate or through their work. Kalam became popular post-Pokhran because the media wanted a popular persona and he with his mane was much better candidate than a pug-faced Vajpayee or a simpler Chidambaram, the other key scientist involved in the process. Apart from him, none of the other bureaucrat politicians have any people backing of their own or any experience in gauging popular issues. They are bureaucrats and they all arrived in the political scene with international exposure just around the time India was opening up to the world(or was it because these people arrived in politics that India opened up to the world?).

his entire career has been in 'opening up' india for financial investments by others at a time when international investments paid little returns in america and europe and people are looking to invest in better parts of the world for better returns and china is still looked at with suspicion. china is no longer looked at with suspicion, the investment there is much higher than us, but, that is a different issue. the issue is if he didn't propel this opening up would someone else have done it? of course, it would have happened, global capital lords would need a different place for better returns and India would have to be opened up in any case. MM Singh and later date Chidambaram are the right people in the right time with the right attitude. they cannot be attributed with any great vision, neither have any. they can be given credit for pushing the global investment agenda through arguments and presentations within the cabinet and ensure that this is never vetoed, they have managed quite well. for this, the media created them to be heroes, they have enjoyed the image and benefited from that too.

his current nuclear deal obsession defies all previous thick headedness by any PM before. it looks like the most beneficial effect would be for corporates that specialize on the nuclear technology, both for military and for civilian purposes. when globally there has been a renewed look on energy afresh and USA doesn't mind even causing global food crisis by diverting its food crops to fuel crops, here we are stuck with obsolete technologies such as coal and large dams on one side and dangerous and white horse technologies such as the nuclear ones to peddle our energy cycle.

we don't really even understand our energy needs. every votary of the nuclear deal has forever recycled the consumption needs of energy 20 years from now, where are these projections from? what is the level of consumption that is anticipated in this kind of consumption? who are the beneficiaries? none seems to bother and none of these questions are posed anyway. economists need to reduce humans to numbers so that they get back to their comfort zone of calculations.

clinton has recently reported to have commented that India and China will burn down the earth. true if the 'american way of life' wins in both these nations today. both the countries have increased their ability to consume and they are consuming at a rate not seen earlier, traditional forms of restrain is no longer valid as (atleast in India) reforms have come about in religious and cultural institutions which synonymously connote abundance with greedy consumption. across the country american way of life has come to be justified by data of how we had materials in abundance 200 years back! this is perverse reading of history too.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

PMs bold advice to the Corporate - why will the genie listen to the master?

Our Prime Minister is often (mistakenly according to his colleague Mani Shankar Iyer) given the credit for what is popularly called the LPG (liberalization, globalization and privatization). Letting the free market situation to emerge in India through the consistent economic policy change (called economic reforms by some) whereby the top of the deck corporates reap all the benefits and the bottom of the pyramid is just about sustained through dole outs. Now the fundamental of the current market paradigm according to economists is that each one to their own, the free market believes that the more selfish the person is the better she would compete and the more healthy it is for the overall health of the market. Period.

Individuals and companies play in the market to maximise their returns of investment, whether it be financial investments, it be career advancement or expansion and acquisition, the fundamental rule is aggrandizements. The methods and tools of the market paradigm are designed towards this purpose, it cannot behave differently. Having let the genie of the market paradigm out through his personal initiatives and initiatives for which he is credited, it was surprise to find the PM make the following statement. Perhaps, the realization that, 'there is enough for every man's need and not everyone's greed' has suddenly hit the PM or there are signs of imminent break out sooner than later that lead to this rather introspective muse. The place where he chose to do it, just like my earlier posting of Iyer's talk was amidst the industrial captains! He must have looked really stranger there.

It is a first in many ways, I don't know when was the last time in the post cold war era an Indian leader openly said that we cannot afford the wasteful western lifestyle. Is this a statement on the much celebrated and proclaimed 'American way of life' that the Super power would want us all to adopt? I think this is perhaps the most striking part of the speech for me, then asking the corporate captains to take a pay cut requires a lot of courage, I do hope he follows it up with a similar request to his own brethren Members of Parliament whose income and perks put together is a major drain on the exchequer though negligible compared to the corporate standards. He also talks of decency and greed being the boundaries of corporate profit maximization, tough luck, neither of these are regulated by the government or anyone else. We have celebrated and venerated Dhirubhai Ambani as a corporate legend, we have even made movies on his life, increasingly our corporates tell their employees and share holders that 'greed accha hai'! The consumer is wooed forever with the promise of any number of choice of products in all categories, and the advertisers go over board to emphasize that it is fine to over consume and all this is the outcome of the LPG.

Anyway, the following are the excerpts from his speech, use the link to read the larger transcript (though rediff repeats itself in reporting)

Source: http://www.rediff.com/money/2007/may/24pm.htm
The Indian industry's success in wealth creation is worth celebrating, but showing off the riches through ostentatious parties is as good as insulting the less privileged and stoking social unrest, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said on Thursday. Apparently turned off by extravagant weddings and other parties thrown by the "rich and the famous," he cautioned that "rising income and wealth inequalities, if not matched by a corresponding rise of incomes across the nation, can lead to social unrest."

Inviting the industry to be the government's partner in creating a humane and just society at CII's annual general meeting here, the prime minister wanted corporate India to first resist excessive remuneration to promoters and senior executives and reduce conspicuous consumption -- as it was "socially undesirable" and "environmentally unsustainable."

"We cannot afford the wasteful lifestyles of the Western world," he said, reminding the industry that India, with over one billion people, ... faces the problem of scarce natural resources on per capita basis.

...He also said that corporate social responsibility must ... be based on the idea that the wealthy have an obligation to society and to nature.... "The time has come for the better off sections of our society to understand the need to make our growth process more inclusive."

Singh said unless workers feel they are cared for at work "we can never evolve a national consensus in favour of more flexible labour laws aimed at ensuring that our firms remain globally competitive."

The prime minister also made it clear that operation of cartels by groups of companies to keep prices high must end."It is unacceptable to obstruct the forces of competition from having fair play. It is even more distressing in a country where the poor are severely affected by rising commodity prices," Singh said.Terming cauterisations as a "crime" that goes against the grain of an open economy, the prime minister said: "Even profit maximisation should be within the bounds of decency and greed."

May be the PM might have felt like a stranger to them, soon there may be news paper columns questioning his sanity, I won't be surprised if someone suggests his name for the next President, a way of saying let us shoe him up, there might be mild reminders that the market cannot accept this by twenty minute political pundits in popular news channels.

The genie would refuse the master is sure by the response from the corporate houses, not one leader actually used the opportunity to make any dramatics and say that he would personally adhere the PM and lead by taking a 5% cut even. Shows the kind of stuff our corporate leaders are made up of.

In Tamil there is a proverb that once you have lost your eyesight it really doesn't matter if you learn suryanamaskaram (a traditional set of yoga postures normally practiced facing the sun at dawn) or not. Mr. Manmohan Singh seems to be doing just that.

Read by Label